Leftists as Elitists 
Leftism IS elitism.... Conservatives think they can learn from the past. Leftists think no-one can tell them anything

The short essay that inspired this blog is here. More on why elites tend Left here.  
  corner   



HOME

ARCHIVES


BIO


People with elitist attitudes tend Left and so do most of those who are actually in elite positions

An interesting saying:
"Egotism is the brain's way of easing the pain of stupidity"

The foundation essay for this blog is here


MY OTHER SITES

DISSECTING LEFTISM

GREENIE WATCH

TONGUE TIED

GUN WATCH

AUSTRALIAN POLITICS

PC WATCH

FOOD & HEALTH SKEPTIC

EDUCATION WATCH INTERNATIONAL

SOCIALIZED MEDICINE

IMMIGRATION WATCH INTERNATIONAL

MARX & ENGELS

SCRIPTURE COMMENTARY

RECIPES

OF INTEREST

OF INTEREST (2)

Of Interest 3

There are also two blogspot blogs which record what I think are my main recent articles here and here

Mirror for "Dissecting Leftism"
China Mirror for "Dissecting Leftism"
Alt archives
Longer Academic Papers
Johnray links
Academic home page
Academic Backup Page
General Backup
General Backup 2



Selected reading

MONOGRAPH ON LEFTISM

CONSERVATISM AS HERESY

Rightism defined
Leftist Churches
Leftist Racism
Fascism is Leftist
Hitler a socialist
What are Leftists
Psychology of Left
Status Quo?
Leftism is authoritarian
James on Leftism
Irbe on Leftism
Beltt on Leftism

Critiques
Lakoff
Van Hiel
Sidanius
Kruglanski



INTERESTING BLOGS
(My frequent reads are starred)

10 o'clock scholar
11 Day Empire
50th Star
Aaron rants
Abercrombie Chick
About Politics
Acidman
Across Atlantic
Agitator*
Albion's Seedling*
Also Canadian
Always Right
AMCGLTD
American Indian Movement
American Mind
American Outlook
American Thinker
American Realpolitik
Anal Philosopher*
Anthropology & Econ
ASTUTE BLOGGERS
Baby Troll
Bad Eagle
Bearpit
Beautiful Atrocities
Belmont Club*
Betsy's Page
Between Coasts
Bidinotto
Bill Keezer
Bill Quick
Bits blog
Bittersweet
Blackfive
Bleeding Brain
Blissful Knowledge
Blogarama
BLOGGER NEWS
Blogs against Hillary
Blogwise
Blood & Guts
Blowhards
Booker Rising
Brian Leiter scrutinized
Brothers Judd*
Bureaucrash
Camp Katrina
Campus Newspaper Confab
Canadian Comment
Candle in dark
Catallarchy*
Chez Joel
Chomsky demolished
Civilian Gun Self defense
Classical Values
Clayton Cramer*
Colby Cosh
Cold Fury
The Commons
Common-sense & Wonder*
Conjecturer
Conservative Eyes
Conservative Grapevine
Conservative Philosopher
Conservative Pleasure
Conservative Voice
Conservatives Anonymous
Country Store
Critical Mass
Cronaca*
Culture Battles
Curmudgeon
Daly Thoughts
Damian Penny
Dancing Dogs
Danegerus
Declarer
Dean's World
Deinonychus antirrhopus
Democratism
Dhimmi Watch
Dick List
Dick McDonald*
Discover the networks
Discriminations
Dodge Blog
Drink This
Dr Helen
Dr Sanity
Drunkablog
Ed Driscoll
Eddy Rants
Electric Venom
Elephants in Academia
Enter Stage Right
Envirospin
Eugene Undergound
Evangelical Ecologist
Everything I Know
Fighting in the Shade
Fourth Rail
Free Patriot
Free Rain
Free Speech
Frizzen Sparks
Galvin Opinion
Gates of Vienna
Gay and Right
Gay Patriot
Gene Expression*
Ghost of Flea
GM's Corner
One Good Turn
Gold Dog
GOP & The City
GOPUSA Alaska
Grooveswitch
Grumpy Old Sod
Gust of Hot Air
Hall of Record
Happy Carpenter
Hatemongers Quart.
Heretical Ideas
R. Hide MP
Hillary's Village
Hitler's Leftism
Hoosier Review
Horsefeathers
Hugh Hewitt
Illumination Inc
IMAO
Inductivist
Infinitely Prolonged
Instapundit
Interested Participant
Jackson's Junction
Jim Kalb
Junk Food science
Justin C Feng
Just One Minute
Keeping it Simple
Kim Du Toit
Knowledge is Power
Kommentariat
Ladybird Deed
La Shawn
Laudator
Let it bleed
Liberal Wrong
Liberty Cadre
Little Green footballs
Logical Meme
Lost Tooth Soc
Lone Wacko
Lubos Motl
Luskin
R. Mandel
Mangan
Mark Nicodemo
Maverick Philosopher
MedPundit
Miami Review
Michelle Malkin
Midwest by DC
Misanthropyst
Moderate Voice
Moorewatch
More Sense than Money
Moved Truth
Mr Minority
Mrs Blessed
Museum of Left Lunacy
My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
National Center
National Security
Neo Con Blogger
Neo Neo-Con
Never Yet Melted
New Media Journal
News Buckit
New Sisyphus
New Victorian
New Zeal Pundit
No Credentials
Norm Quantum Weatherby
Northeastern Intelligence Network
OC Register blog
Orator
Overlawyered
Pakman
Pajama Editors
Parable Man
ParaPundit*
PC Stupidity
Pedestrian Infidel
Pejmanesque
Petrified Truth
Poli Pundit
Political Psychology
Political Theory Review
Pragmatic Libertarian
Prof Bainbridge
Promethean
Proportional Belief
Publius Pundit
Qando
Random Observations
Rand Simberg
Random Jottings
Ravenwood
Raving Atheist
Reagan Baby
Red State
Redwood Dragon
Regions of Mind
Rhodey
Rhymes with Right
Right Faith
Right Nation
Right Reason
Right Spin
Rightwing Troll
Right Thinking
Right Wing news
Roadkill
Ron Hebron
Rottweiler
Sayet Right
SCSU Scholars*
Sean Lafreniere
Seitelplasm
Sharp Blades
Sharp Knife
Should Know
Silflay Hraka
Silent Running
Sine Qua Non
Smallest Minority
Spartac.us
Spelled Sideways
Squander 2
Stephen Frank
Steve Sailer
Stop and Think
Stop the ACLU
Stuart Buck
Talking Head
Tim Worstall
Townhall C-log
Truth Laid Bear
Two-Four Net
Unca Dave
Vdare blog
Verbum Ipsum
Viking Pundit
Vodka Pundit
Voices in Head
Western Standard
Bill Whittle
What If
Whym Rhymer
WICKED THOUGHTS*
Winds of Change
Wizbang
World of Reason
Write Wing Warrior
You Big Mouth
Zero Intelligence



Education Blogs

Early Childhood Education
Education Wonks
EducatioNation
Eduwonk
Homeschool Blogger
Joanne Jacobs*
Marc Miyake*
No 2 Pencil
Weary Teacher



Economics Blogs

Adam Smith
Arnold Kling
Chicago Boyz
Cafe Hayek
Econopundit
Environmental Economics
Environmental Economics & Sust. Devel.
Innocents Abroad
Jane Galt
S. Karlson
D. Luskin
Marginal Revolution
Mises Inst.
Robert Musil
Truck & Barter


Australian Blogs


Tim Blair
A E Brain
Brookes news
The Bunyip
Catallaxy
Chrenkoff
Currency lad
Daily Constitutional
Emotional Rex
Evil Pundit
Kev Gillett
Hissink File
L. Hissink's Crazy World
ICJS*
Little Tin Soldier
M4 Monologues
M Jennings
Mangled Thoughts
Media Dragon
Oz Conservative
Pommygranate
Rational Thoughts
Slattery
Tao of Defiance
Troppo
Voice of Pacific
Wog Blog
WESTERN HEART*
The Yobbo
Bastards Inc
Paul & Carl
It's A Matter of Opinion
Cyclone's Sketchblog
Niner Charlie
Greyice
The Dog Blog
Welcome to the Asylum
Grinder-Com
Chris Berg



England

Blimpish
Blithering Bunny
BNP and Me
Briffa
Britain & America
British Interest
Burning our Money
Campaign Against Political Correctness
Campaign for English Parliament
Conservative Comment
Daily Ablution
England Project
EU Serf
Norm Geras
House of Dumb
IQ & PC
Liberty Cadre
Limbic Nutrition
Majority Rights*
Melanie Phillips
NHS Doctor
Oliver Kamm
Policeman
Mike Power
Right to be Free
Samizdata
Sean Gabb
Natalie Solent
Sterling Times
Walking the Streets
Wayne Smallman
Rich Webster
Englishman's Castle



Scotland

Freedom & Whisky
Highland Warrior
A Place to Stand



Wales

Brit Nats in Wales



Ireland

Conservative Dubliner
Tangled Web



Iceland

Ice & Fire
Great Auk



ISRAEL

Israel Pundit
IsraPundit
Not A Fish
Steven Plaut
Rishon
Think Israel




The Portuguese connection

A Razao das Coisas
Avaliando o mundo
Blasfemias
Blogoesfera Internacional
Boticario de Provincia
De Direita
Direita
Impertinencias
Jaquinzinhos
Nadando contra a mare
Nortadas
O Intermitente
O Reacionario
O Blog do Alex
Portugal Liberal
Super Flumina
Ser Portugues
Tempestade Cerebral
Valete Fratres



Other Europe


Daily Bork
Davids Medienkritik
European Family Health
HispaLibertas
No Pasaran
Le Guerre Civili
Tommy Funebo



AFRICA

Almost Supernatural
Ethiopian Pundit



BIGGIES
Ananova
Beeb
Best of Web
Business Review Weekly
Business Week
Centcom (Iraq)
Courier Mail
Dilby News
Dinkum Oz
Economist
Free Republic
Fin Review
Fortune
Forbes
Front Page
Human events
Intellectual Conservative
International Business Times
Junk Science
National Review
Newsback
Slate
Sydney Morning Harold
Telegraph (London)
Thunderer (London)



Archives:

03/01/2003 - 04/01/2003 05/01/2004 - 06/01/2004 06/01/2004 - 07/01/2004 07/01/2004 - 08/01/2004 08/01/2004 - 09/01/2004 09/01/2004 - 10/01/2004 10/01/2004 - 11/01/2004 11/01/2004 - 12/01/2004 12/01/2004 - 01/01/2005 01/01/2005 - 02/01/2005 02/01/2005 - 03/01/2005 03/01/2005 - 04/01/2005 04/01/2005 - 05/01/2005 05/01/2005 - 06/01/2005 06/01/2005 - 07/01/2005 07/01/2005 - 08/01/2005 08/01/2005 - 09/01/2005 09/01/2005 - 10/01/2005 10/01/2005 - 11/01/2005 03/01/2007 - 04/01/2007 05/01/2007 - 06/01/2007 06/01/2007 - 07/01/2007


Site Feed



Who Links Here

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?
 

Friday, September 02, 2005

 
THE "ART" ESTABLISMENT SPONGES OFF TAXPAYERS WHO DON'T GIVE A FIG FOR THEM

Their work isn't popular enough to earn them a living, so our artists grasp the taxpayer teat. It's not how we should be spending our money. When the Bracks [Victorian] Government spends $96,000 to paint trees blue, you see again why politicians and bureaucrats shouldn't be handing your money to artists. This is what you get when someone takes your taxes to buy art no one likes enough to buy themselves. Just ask yourself -- when you heard 40 elms at Yarra Park would be painted the colour of sad, didn't you instantly guess government money was involved? Who else would spend so much on something so unwanted?

But let's not miss the wood for the blue trees. The real worry isn't discoloured elms, but distracted artists -- artists who are paid by governments to ignore their true audience, the public. It's bizarre. In fact, our biggest arts grants are now going to middle-aged or elderly artists who -- even after decades of "success" -- still seem not to have found an audience big enough to pay them a living.

This month the arts and craft board of the Australia Council announced another round of grants worth more than $2 million. The biggest handouts were four fellowships each worth $80,000, given to arty-crafty people of "outstanding achievement . . . to create new work and further develop their practice". The winners all had decades of work behind them -- Klaus Moje (born in 1936), Jenny Watson (1951), Fiona Hall (1953) and Joyce Hinterding (1958). All had also had huge success, or as huge as it gets in art-crafts. Between them, they'd won countless awards, folders of fawning reviews and earlier grants and fellowships. The arts establishment had also variously given them jobs as lecturers, stints as artists-in-residence and hanging space in scores of public galleries, here and overseas.

Yet despite all that, they still need our money -- not freely given, but extracted through taxation -- to keep making what they make. Given that Moje, a glass-worker, is now 69, can we ever expect an artist to stand on his own two feet -- or try another line of work? As I said, these are artists much praised, but when you look at what they do, you might understand why they still need a grant. The Australia Council says Hinterding, for instance, will use her $80,000 to "create, exhibit and perform with a series of printed graphic antennae". The advertising for her works describes them best: "(They are) based on celestial site recordings of magnetic fields and weather satellites made with custom-built antennae . . . The result is a complex universe of mysterious interference, ghostly transmissions from unfathomable places, disembodied static, and failed communication."

It sounds kind of interesting for 30 seconds, but must taxpayers be forced to give Hinterding $80,000 to keep producing examples of this failed communication Would they even care if her antennae never again tuned in to mysterious interference? Perhaps not, because if they did, they'd support Hinterding in sales, not grants.

I should add that I don't dislike her art, or that of the others. I even like the way Fiona Hall carves flowers from sardine tins, knits baby clothes from Coca-Cola cans and builds bird nests out of shredded US dollar bills. I just doubt many people would buy it, which may be why she applied for this fellowship. But why must we be forced to pay for art that we do not choose to buy? Why must we pay all the other art and crafts people who got smaller grants to create "a new body of work in transparent rubber", or "photomedia works based on Prato in Tuscany" (Tuscany again!) or "a series of lighting pieces conceptually based on characteristics of a dysfunctional family"? Why pay for all this?

Writer Rodney Hall, former head of the Australia Council, tried to justify it in a paper written last month for the federal Labor Party. "The arts make us feel better," he declared. Like aspirin, I guess. Or beer. If that's so, I'm surprised so few artists seem all that happy. In fact, Hall seems especially unhappy, especially when contemplating the arts that are meant to make him "feel better". In his paper, he groans that our books have got worse, and so have our films. Indeed: "It is glaringly obvious that international distributors are not at all interested in Australia (sic) products because they are Australian." And at a recent Opera Australia performance he was horrified to find singers could "not even sing the notes".

All this has happened as our governments spend more than ever on artists. Yet Rodney Hall, and our politicians, just don't see the link -- that as the state spends more, our arts tend to get worse (or so Mr Hall says). Hall instead clings to the conceit that popular art is trash art -- the poisonous conceit that explains why we keep funding the unpopular stuff instead. "Especially if it has power and lasting value, it is seldom immediately assimilable and therefore seldom immediately popular," he claims. Well, you might want to believe this too, if you wrote books as ignored as the grant-fed Hall's.

The truth is, of course, great artists must rarely wait to become popular. Beethoven, Dickens, Hemingway, Picasso, T.S. Eliot, Walt Whitman, Verdi -- all were celebrities in their day, and didn't need the state's help to create. It's state money, direct to artists, that corrupts them, in part by helping them to forget it takes two for art to succeed -- someone to create and someone to enjoy. Take the audience out of that marriage, and art withers, flowers fade and -- heavens! -- even the very trees turn blue


From Andrew Bolt





This page is powered by Blogger.